Skip to main content

US Economic Competitiveness at Risk: A Midwest Call to Action

RESEARCH Report by Tamar Jacoby , Chet Culver , Richard M. Daley , Doris Meissner , Clare Muñana , Michael Rounds , John Rowe , Samuel C. Scott III , Carole Segal , and Joe Loughrey
An illuminated OPEN sign outside of a business
Prateek Katyal

This report highlights the role of immigration in ensuring the Midwest’s future competitiveness and prosperity and identifies necessary policy directions or interventions.

Bipartisan Task Force

The Chicago Council on Global Affairs launched a bipartisan task force in December 2011 to inform Midwestern leadership and public understanding of immigration and its importance to the region’s economic future. The task force seeks to forge consensus around, and build support for, sensible immigration policy at the state and national levels.

Led by nine co-chairs, the task force is comprised of approximately 40 members from across the Midwest, including private sector leaders (from Fortune 500 companies, Midwestern farm bureaus and entrepreneurs), subject matter experts, policy practitioners, and civic leaders (including religious leaders and presidents of universities and foundations). Together they developed a report that outlines the rationale and key principles needed for sound immigration policy.

On February 28, 2013, task force cochairs and members participated in an immigration summit in Washington, DC where the report, US Economic Competitiveness at Risk: A Midwest Call to Action on Immigration Reform, was released. The report highlights the role of immigration in ensuring the Midwest’s future competitiveness and prosperity and identifies necessary policy directions or interventions.

Task force accomplishments and ongoing activities include:
  • Conducted a survey on Midwest views on immigration. Developed, fielded, analyzed, and reported on the views of over 1000 Midwesterners and compared them to national responses.
  • Hosted a series of Midwest immigration forums. The task force generated public discussions and engagement through a set of immigration forums around the twelve-state Midwest region during the summer of 2012. These forums provided the opportunity for discussion of the task force’s draft report and assessed how closely the report reflected the realities of immigration in communities across the Midwest.  
  •  Launched an immigration-focused website. Develop and launch a new micro site focused on Immigration in the Midwest including demographics from each state, the role of immigration in the past and current local economy, key policy issues contested in each state, among other topics.
  • Assembling the Group of 500. The task force will attract a Group of 500 Midwestern leaders and organizations in support of the group’s findings.
  • Commissioned Spotlight Stories. Nine spotlight stories chosen for their regional diversity, illustration of high- and low-skilled labor, and their ability to highlight one or more key aspects of the immigration debate in the Midwest will be published in the final report.
  • Commissioned New Midwest Data. New research data on immigrants in the Midwest and their population trends, regions of origin, education levels, and occupations will be published in the final report.
  • Releasing a final report. The task force will produce a final report articulating the Midwest’s stake in immigration and make clear what the region needs fixed for it to remain economically competitive.  The report is scheduled to be release on February 28, 2013 in Washington, D.C.
  • Undertake dissemination efforts. Communicate the key findings and views of the Group of 500 to key Midwestern constituencies, national opinion leaders, and policymakers in Washington, DC.
About the Authors
Tamar Jacoby
President and CEO, ImmigrationWorks USA
Tamar Jacoby is a nationally known journalist and author. She has also served as a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, as a senior writer and justice editor for Newsweek, and as the deputy editor of The New York Times op-ed page. She is currently a Schwartz Fellow at the New America Foundation.
Chet Culver
Former Governor of Iowa
Headshot for Chet Culver
Governor Chet Culver served two terms as Iowa’s secretary of state and was then elected governor in 2006. Governor Culver has been appointed by President Obama and by the US Senate and currently serves on the board with the Farmer Mac. Most recently he has founded the Chet Culver Group, a renewable energy efficiency and infrastructure consultancy.
Headshot for Chet Culver
Richard M. Daley
Former Mayor, City of Chicago
Richard M. Daley talks into a microphone at an event
Richard M. Daley is the longest-serving mayor in Chicago’s history. Prior to his 22-year tenure as mayor, he was a state senator and county prosecutor. He now serves as a distinguished senior fellow at the University of Chicago’s Harris School of Public Policy and as of counsel to Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP, a national law firm based in Chicago.
Richard M. Daley talks into a microphone at an event
Doris Meissner
Former Commissioner, US Immigration and Naturalization Service
Doris Meissner is a senior fellow at the Migration Policy Institute, where she directs the institute’s US immigration policy work. From 1993-2000, she served in the Clinton administration as commissioner of the INS. Her accomplishments included reforming the nation's asylum system, creating new strategies for managing US borders, and much more.
Clare Muñana
President, Ancora Associates, Inc.
Clare Muñana is a public sector, not-for-profit, and international management consultant operating her own firm. Mayor Richard M. Daley appointed her as a member of the Chicago Board of Education in 1999 and she was then elected by the board members in 2004 as the vice president of the Board of Education of the City of Chicago.
Michael Rounds
Former Governor of South Dakota
Headshot of Mike Rounds
M. Michael “Mike” Rounds served five terms in the South Dakota State Senate. In 1995 he was chosen by his peers to serve as Senate majority leader, a post he held for six years. Rounds was sworn in as South Dakota’s 31st governor in 2003 and reelected in 2006. He has now returned to his insurance and real estate business.
Headshot of Mike Rounds
John Rowe
Chairman Emeritus, Exelon Corporation
John W. Rowe is the chairman emeritus of the Chicago-based Exelon Corporation, one of the nation’s largest electric utilities. He previously worked with New England Electric System, Central Maine Power Company, Consolidated Rail Corporation, and at the law firm of Isham, Lincoln & Beale. In both 2008 and 2009, Institutional Investor named Rowe the best electric utility CEO in America.
Samuel C. Scott III
Board of Directors Cochair, Chicago Council on Global Affairs
Board of Directors Cochair Samuel C. Scott III
Samuel C. Scott III is the retired Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer of Corn Products International, Inc., today known as Ingredion. He currently serves on the board of The Bank of New York Mellon where he is Chairman of the Corporate Governance, Nominating, and Social Responsibility Committee. From 1993-2019 he sat on the board of Motorola Solutions, Inc., retiring as their Lead Director, and was on the board of Abbott Laboratories from 2007-2020.
Board of Directors Cochair Samuel C. Scott III
Carole Segal
Co-Founder, Crate and Barrel
Carole Segal is the founder and former CEO of Foodstuffs, and the president of the Segal Family Foundation. Segal is a trustee of Rush University Medical Center and chairman of the board of overseers at Rush University. She is a trustee emeritus of Bates College, a life trustee of the Illinois Institute of Technology, and a member of the board of directors of WBEZ-Chicago Public Media.
Joe Loughrey
Former President and COO, Cummins, Inc.
Joe Loughrey was with Cummins Inc., the world’s largest independent diesel engine manufacturer, for over 35 years until he retired in 2009. He served as vice-chairman of Cummins, as president and chief operating officer, and was a member of its board of directors and the board of The Cummins Foundation.